A guide to Dictionaries of Latin synonyms – How to tell the difference

 
a guide to dictionaries of Latin Synonyms, what is the difference.png

Has this ever happened to you?

You’re happily reading a Latin text when you come across a word you’re not sure about.

You open the dictionary, look up the word, learn the definition, go back to reading.

A little further down you stumble on another word. Same thing. Look up the word, learn the… and confusion sets in. The two words have basically the same definition.

“What’s the difference?” “Is there a difference?”

After reading this article you’ll know how to solve these age-old questions.



Introduction

Do nuances matter?

Through the years, I have spent many a night pondering the difference in meaning between so called synonyms, in order to better understand the nuances of the text. I have learned an immense amount from dictionaries of Latin synonyms through the years. But are they necessary?

Frankly, while reading a text, you can often do without knowing the precise nuance a word carries; a general notion will often suffice to pull you through to the author’s next thought. 

But if you desire to deepen your knowledge of Latin, and peer through the seams of synonyms, or to drape your own thoughts with just the right words, you need to study the differences in meaning.

This can be a challenge but fortunately there is help…

Where to start? 

Scholars have been writing on Latin synonyms and their differences from antiquity (e.g. Varro, and later Isidore of Seville) to today.

life-863148_1280.jpg

In the 19th century the genre flourished with a host of authors penning dictionaries of Latin synonyms but, sine cura sis, I won’t list them all.

Here I will rather focus on particularly useful ones that I use in my own reading and research. 

They date from the 18th to the 20th centuries.  

I will present the most exhaustive ones first, more suitable for advanced studies, and then move on to more accessible works.

Luckily, all these dictionaries of Latin synonyms are available as PDFs, to which I have added  download links.

Comprehensive works

Let’s first look at the two principal works, one French and one German.

Gardin Dumesnil

First out is J.B. Gardin Dumesnil's, Synonymes Latins et leurs significations, first published in 1777, but revised and translated several times.

A dictionary of Latin synonyms: Synonymes latins et leurs différentes significations, Gardin Dumesil.

This is a comprehensive work, containing 7000 groups of synonyms. The descriptions given are brief with examples from Latin authors. There are few, if any, discussions on the distinctions made.

For that we need to turn to the next work on our list.


640px-Johann_Ludwig_Christoph_Wilhelm_von_Döderlein.jpg

The most comprehensive work on Latin synonyms by far is Ludwig Döderlein’s monumental Lateinische Synonyme und Etymologieen (1826–1838). 

In six volumes he unveils the differences between words, giving deeply detailed descriptions while providing his reasoning and arguments for establishing them. 

A dictionary of Latin synonyms: Ludwig Döderlein, Lateinische Synonyme und Etymologieen.

Sometimes there is a hint of absurda diligentia which is always amusing.  

Unfortunately, it is only available in German. (Be the first to learn German through a dictionary of Latin synonyms?)

Short & abridged: QUICK FIX?

Sometimes your German fails you, or you just don't need all the 7000 words from Dumesnil. If so, there are several shorter works. 

speedometer-653246_1280.jpg

Ramshorn

Ludwig Ramshorn, the German translator of Dumesnil’s work, also published an abridged version of the dictionary for schools.

The descriptions are short without any discussions or arguments for his definitions, making it more accessible and suitable for a quick look. 

Its English translation also contains a section on morphology. 

Download the PDF here:


Döderlein no.2

Döderlein – whose hand penned six volumes on Latin synonyms – seems to have realised that readers wanted a more streamlined work, some light reading, if you will, so he published an abridged version. 

It keeps the various distinctions while dispensing with the reasoning and argumentation behind them.

A dictionary of Latin synonyms: Handobook of Latin Synonyms by Ludwig Döderlein.

The abridged work has the added benefit of being available in several languages (English, French and German).

Download PDFs of the work in here:


DouthaT

In brevity and clarity Robert Douthat’s Latin synonymes defined from two standpoints takes the first prize.

To delineate the differences, he moves from the generic to the specific: starting by defining the simple verb (e.g. “habere”) he moves on to compounds (e.g. “exhibeo”).

Dictionary of Latin synonyms (Douthay 1907)

This disposition makes it drastically different from the other dictionaries but quite interesting. 

Download the PDF here: 


latin only: Stayin’ in Latin 

Thus far we’ve talked about vernacular dictionaries of Latin synonyms. Now it’s time to move on to one wholly in Latin.

Popma

Ausonius Popma’s dictionary of Latin synonyms De differentiis verborum (Turin 1852) gives detailed yet succinct explanations of the differences in meaning, all in Latin.

In comprehensiveness it compares to Ramshorn’s abridged version of Dumesnil.

Popma’s strength is that it’s written entirely in Latin, keeping you thinking in Latin: While looking up a word you’re building your knowledge of synonyms as well as acquiring the vocabulary necessary to discuss differences of meaning in Latin.

A priceless skill.

Dictionary of Latin synonyms: Ausonius Popma, De differentiis

Latin DICTIONARY with SYNONYMS

Wagner

Wagner’s Lexicon Latinum is something in between a regular Latin dictionary and a dictionary of Latin synonyms.

Wagner.png

When you look up a word you get the vernacular definition (German, French, Italian, English – depending on the edition) as well as several synonyms, but without explanations as to the different shades of meaning.

With each definition you also get an example of its use.

Lexicon Latinum, Wagner. A dictionary of Latin synonyms.

This compact and useful work provides an overview of the word and its synonyms without discussing their differences.

Download the PDF:  

Wagner’s Lexicon Latinum is also available as a searchable digital resource here.


Eng-Lat: BEGINNING to write Latin?

Ogilvie

Last but not least is Prof. Robert Ogilvie’s Horae Latinae; its aim and structure is quite different from other works on Latin synonyms:

Written for composing Latin prose, it gives the Latin equivalents of about 500 English expressions.

It lists the English words or expressions with descriptions of the various ways in which they are to be rendered into Latin.

The definitions are accompanied by many examples taken from classical works. 

horae-latinae-latin-synonyms-at-latinitium.com.png

DO You believe in synonyms?

A note of warning.

Dumesnil, Döderlein, Popma and the rest have sometimes cut too fine lines between synonyms, differentiating shades of meaning that classical authors do not always observe (o audaciam!).

The difference between words doesn’t necessarily lie in meaning but in register, style, genre, author or time period.

So look to these works for guidance rather than revelations of hidden truths. Compare their definitions with your own view. They do not supplant reading widely and acquiring an intuitive feeling for Latin.  

Overview: Which is best?

We’ve looked at the major works and it’s time to take the next step: using them.

Which one? you may ask. It depends on your situation and need. They all have their strengths. If pressed, I would suggest using a couple in conjunction.

Overview of dictionaries of Latin synonyms

Regular dictionary with synonyms:

English–Latin: great for writing Latin:

Shorter dictionaries for quick answers:

All in Latin – For staying in Latin: 

Wide selection of words and brief explanations:

The most exhaustive with detailed discussions: 

Ready to start?

travel-1756152_1280.jpg

Unraveling the the web of differences can be a hair-pulling, frustrating endeavour. 

It’s tempting to write off two synonymous words as identical in meaning. Don’t.

The next time you ask yourself “what’s the difference between…?” I’m sure you’ll go the extra mille passuum and take out your Dumesnil, Döderlein or Popma.

You’ll discover the differences that ultimately bring you closer to the text, to understanding it as the author (may have) intended.